- #Ancient greek question mark loeb how to
- #Ancient greek question mark loeb full
- #Ancient greek question mark loeb professional
In fact, you need not, and should not, concentrate upon demolishing prior views but rather on expounding your own reading in the most positive and compelling light if your conclusions can be readily integrated into the current communis opinio, so much the better. Sarcasm and extended polemic are out of place. You may need to correct an earlier interpretation if so, do so briefly and tactfully, ideally in a footnote. Keep your thesis firmly in mind and don't digress. While you can certainly base an article upon research you've done for your dissertation, the material should be set forth differently in keeping with the above guidelines.Īn article should deal with one, and only one, scholarly issue, presenting your arguments and conclusions as succinctly as possible. The listing won't carry much weight with a search committee, and you'll be wasting the referees' time, as well as postage. We suggest you politely ignore that advice. When you go on the job market, a well-meaning mentor may urge you to send off a chapter of your dissertation "as is" so that you'll be able to list an item "under editorial review" on your curriculum vitae while getting feedback from referees. Your mission is to educate them, to give them the gift of your knowledge and insights, not to defend yourself against their potential criticisms. Relatively few of these readers will know more than you do about the topic, or even as much as you do. It may also be of interest to scholars in other disciplines and to members of the general public.
#Ancient greek question mark loeb professional
The article, on the other hand, is addressed to a wide audience of fellow classicists-a group that may well include high school, undergraduate, and graduate students as well as your professional colleagues. Consequently, you spent a good deal of time explaining, and reacting to, the views of virtually every scholar who had dealt with this question earlier.
#Ancient greek question mark loeb full
There you needed to demonstrate to your professors that you had full control of the relevant primary and secondary sources and had grasped all the positive and negative implications of a given scrap of evidence. Your dissertation was composed for the members of your thesis committee, especially your dissertation director. While both may deal with the same set of issues, they appeal to different audiences and serve different purposes.
#Ancient greek question mark loeb how to
For tips on how to set it in motion, see Appendix B.Īn article is not the same thing as a dissertation chapter. If so, they need to undergo a long conversion process. Published articles may begin their lives as seminar papers. While the boundaries of scholarly style have expanded in recent years, most editors and readers evaluate articles by these traditional criteria. If the author makes a lucid and persuasive case for his or her opinion, the article is successful. In a scholarly article, the author sets forth a thesis about a given topic and attempts to convince an audience of its validity. Consequently, it is the author's obligation to articulate his or her meaning explicitly, instead of asking the reader to infer it, as the literary artist does. A piece of expository writing tries to present information and arguments as clearly as possible. Scholarly articles belong to the larger genre of expository writing. We hope you will find at least some of the advice useful. While our opinions are strictly personal, and may on occasion seem idiosyncratic, they represent what we would be likely to say to any of our graduate students who asked us for tips about publishing in this field. write a good first article, choose the right venue for it, and successfully submit it for publication. It is designed to help a graduate student or recent Ph.D. The following guide to scholarly publishing has been compiled by two former editors of TAPA. A Guide for New Members of the Profession